AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault: Who wins?

Every developer is familiar with that cold sweat moment when a critical API key, database password, or encryption certificate is accidentally left exposed. Because today, a single misplaced secret can be a catastrophic vulnerability just waiting to be exploited.

As systems become more distributed, compliance requirements tighten, and architectures become increasingly dynamic, secrets management evolves from a best practice into a non-negotiable discipline. Two of the most powerful tools for addressing this challenge are AWS Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault. While both aim to provide secure and efficient management of secrets, they differ significantly in design philosophy, integration options, and feature sets.

Hard-coding credentials or relying on unsafe practices dramatically increases the risk of data breaches and compliance failures. But how do you choose the right tool for the job when faced with powerful options like AWS Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault?

In this newsletter, we'll cover what modern secrets management involves and how AWS Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault resolve these challenges. We also look into what each offers in terms of features and extensibility, along with how to evaluate their operational complexity through real-world use cases.

Let’s explore what these tools do, and why getting secrets right is essential for building secure and resilient systems.

Understanding the secret life cycle from creation to expiration#

At a glance, secrets management might seem like simply storing a password somewhere safe. But the life cycle of a secret is much more complex. From the moment it’s created, a secret should be rigorously controlled, encrypted at rest, accessed only by authorized principals, and rotated frequently to prevent stale credentials from lingering in your system.

More advanced secrets managers not only automate these tasks but also offer dynamic secrets, which are credentials generated on demand for a specific user or application with a short expiration window. This reduces the blast radius and significantly limits what an attacker could do with leaked access. To manage secrets effectively, it’s important to follow a structured life cycle, beginning with creation and progressing through usage, rotation, expiration, and finally, revocation. These stages ensure that every secret is securely provisioned, properly used, regularly updated, and ultimately retired or revoked when no longer needed.

Modern DevOps teams need secrets managers that are programmatically accessible, compliant with audit standards, and robust enough to support multi-region and multi-cloud environments.

What each tool offers for modern secrets management#

At their core, both Amazon Web Services (AWS) Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault address the critical need for secure storage, access, and rotation of sensitive information such as application programming interface (API) keys, database credentials, and digital certificates. However, they approach this problem through different architectural philosophies, resulting in distinct strengths and trade-offs.

AWS Secrets Manager is a fully managed service designed primarily for Amazon Web Services (AWS) environments, but also supports hybrid and multi-cloud applications through features like IAM Roles Anywhere. It simplifies secrets management within the cloud by offering seamless integration with other AWS services, and automated rotation for various AWS-native resources.

HashiCorp Vault is a flexible, cloud-agnostic solution that can be deployed as a self-hosted system, or consumed as a managed service through the HashiCorp Cloud Platform (HCP) Vault Dedicated. It offers advanced features for secrets management, encryption as a service, and privileged access workflows, making it ideal for multi-cloud and hybrid infrastructure environments.

Why AWS Secrets Manager is ideal for AWS-native workloads#

AWS Secrets Manager is designed for ease of use and integration. As a fully managed service, it handles provisioning, scaling, and availability out of the box. It’s ideal for AWS-native workloads that need secure secret storage with minimal configuration.

Some of its most valuable features include:

• Built-in automatic rotation for Amazon Relational Database Service (Amazon RDS), Amazon Redshift, and Amazon DocumentDB, using pre-configured AWS Lambda function templates.

• Deep integration with AWS Identity and Access Management (AWS IAM), enabling permission delegation, scoped access, and resource-based policy enforcement.

• Multi-Region replication, which enhances high availability and simplifies disaster recovery (DR) across multiple AWS Availability Zones.

• AWS CloudTrail and Amazon CloudWatch integration, providing detailed visibility into secret access events and real-time monitoring for compliance and alerting.

• Secret versioning, allowing users to revert to previous secret values or review historical versions for audit purposes.

• Client-side caching, which improves application performance by reducing the need for frequent API calls and lowering associated request costs.

AWS Secrets Manager workflow#

AWS Secrets Manager works by encrypting your secrets, like database passwords or API keys, using AWS Key Management Service (KMS). It can automatically rotate these secrets on a defined schedule using AWS Lambda, so you don’t have to manage them manually. Applications securely retrieve the secrets at runtime to connect to AWS services like RDS and Redshift, or even external systems. CloudTrail logs access for audit compliance, while CloudWatch helps you monitor secret usage and set up alerts.

Example#

A fintech startup that handles payment processing, the back-end system runs on Amazon Elastic Container Service (Amazon ECS), with services that interact with customer data stored in Amazon Relational Database Service (Amazon RDS). To meet Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) compliance and avoid the risks of hardcoded credentials, the team integrates AWS Secrets Manager to manage their database passwords. AWS Secrets Manager automatically rotates the Amazon RDS credentials every 24 hours using AWS Lambda functions. Meanwhile, the Amazon ECS tasks retrieve the updated secrets securely through AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) task roles at runtime. AWS CloudTrail logs every secret access event, helping the security team maintain a verifiable audit trail without adding manual overhead. This setup allows the team to meet compliance requirements, reduce credential exposure, and scale securely within the Amazon Web Services (AWS) ecosystem.

How HashiCorp Vault delivers deep control across clouds#

In contrast, HashiCorp Vault is built for maximum flexibility, security, and portability. It is cloud-neutral and functions seamlessly across Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud Platform (GCP), on-premises data centers, and even edge environments. This makes Vault an ideal choice for teams operating in heterogeneous infrastructure environments, or those with strict regulatory and compliance requirements.

Key features that make HashiCorp Vault stand out include:

• Dynamic secrets for databases, cloud providers, Secure Shell (SSH) sessions, and more. These are generated on demand and are automatically revoked after expiration.

• Flexible authentication backends, supporting identity providers such as OpenID Connect (OIDC), Lightweight Directory Access Protocol (LDAP), GitHub, Kubernetes ServiceAccounts, AppRole, and AWS Identity and Access Management (AWS IAM).

• Policy-based access control defined using HashiCorp Configuration Language (HCL), with support for multi-factor authentication (MFA) and group-based access permissions.

• Tamper-evident, append-only audit logs, optionally hashed and integrated with Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) systems.

• The Vault transit secrets engine allows applications to offload encryption and decryption operations without exposing raw keys, enhancing cryptographic security.

• High availability (HA), replication, and disaster recovery (DR) capabilities offered through Vault Enterprise for robust, globally distributed deployments.

• Kubernetes-native integrations, such as the Vault Agent Injector and Container Storage Interface (CSI) driver, for automated and secure secret delivery to containerized workloads.

Vault workflow#

The HashiCorp Vault core workflow begins when a client authenticates using an identity source such as GitHub, Lightweight Directory Access Protocol (LDAP), or AppRole. Vault then validates the client’s identity, authorizes access based on defined policies, and finally grants access to secrets or cryptographic operations. Each step is strictly enforced by Vault’s policy engine to uphold least-privilege access principles and ensure complete auditability.

Example#

A large financial services enterprise operates hundreds of microservices across both Google Cloud Platform (GCP) and Amazon Web Services (AWS). These services need secure, real-time access to multiple MySQL databases spread across their cloud environments. To eliminate the risk of long-lived, static credentials, the company implements HashiCorp Vault to dynamically generate short-lived database credentials for each service instance. Each service authenticates to Vault using OpenID Connect (OIDC), allowing Vault to verify the service identity and issue credentials with strict time-to-live (TTL) constraints. Once issued, the credentials are automatically revoked after their expiration window, drastically reducing the attack surface. Every interaction with Vault is recorded in its tamper-evident, append-only audit logs, enabling organizations to meet financial industry compliance standards and perform detailed forensic analysis during audits. This setup gives the organization precise access control, visibility, and security across multiple cloud providers. This is essential for operating in a zero-trust, regulated environment.

Deciding which tool fits our use case#

Choosing the right option is not about the number of features or popularity; it’s about what best fits our context.

When AWS Secrets Manager is the better choice:

• You operate primarily on AWS or in hybrid environments and want native integration with optional support for external systems.

• You prefer a fully managed solution with minimal overhead.

• You’re managing secrets mostly for AWS-native resources like RDS or Lambda.

• You want automatic rotation for standard databases and cloud credentials.

When HashiCorp Vault is the better choice:

• You operate in complex multi-cloud, hybrid, or on-premises environments and need a cloud-agnostic solution with flexible deployment options.

• You need ephemeral, dynamic secrets that are generated on demand and automatically revoked after a short time to live (TTL).

• You require fine-grained, identity-based access control using a wide variety of authentication backends (e.g., OpenID Connect, GitHub, LDAP, Kubernetes, AppRole).

• You need tamper-evident audit logs, along with native secret expiration and lease revocation capabilities for high-compliance environments.

• You can manage the operational complexity of self-hosting (or prefer the managed HCP Vault offering for ease) and expect greater extensibility and customization.

What to expect from the setup, learning curve, and operations:

• AWS Secrets Manager has a relatively low learning curve. If your team is already familiar with IAM, you’ll be productive quickly. AWS handles infrastructure concerns; it is perfect for developers who want to focus on building, not maintaining systems.

• HashiCorp Vault requires deeper expertise, especially when self-hosted. You’ll need to understand cluster setup, storage backends, and network configuration. But for teams that require complete control and flexibility, the investment pays off. Notably, HCP Vault Dedicated bridges this gap, offering the full power of Vault with reduced management effort.

Feature comparison between AWS Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault#

Here’s how AWS Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault stack up across key features developers care about most:

Wrapping up#

Both AWS Secrets Manager and HashiCorp Vault stand as powerful, enterprise-grade solutions for robust secrets management. The optimal choice isn’t about one being inherently “better,” but rather which solution best aligns with your organization’s unique architecture, stringent security, and compliance needs. Most of all, it should be compatible with your team’s operational capacity and budget.

Factors such as whether your infrastructure is strictly AWS-centric or requires a versatile multi-cloud approach should also be considered. Along with that, queries around whether your security goals necessitate advanced features (like ephemeral dynamic secrets or generalized encryption-as-a-service) beyond basic encrypted storage and rotation, will guide you further.

Ultimately, considering your team’s bandwidth for managing a complex system vs. preferring a fully managed platform (and the associated costs) will be paramount in selecting the solution that enhances your security posture. This, in turn, will establish a strong foundation for secure scaling.

For more on this topic, definitely check out some of our popular courses: