Machine learning education: university vs. online

May 13, 2019 - 4 min read
James Wu
editor-page-cover

Today, we’re continuing our discussion with ML veteran, Allen Lu of Adaptilab, on his experience working on machine learning at Google and Microsoft.

Below, we’ll discuss the current state of machine learning education, specifically in the context of helping people succeed in industry engineering jobs.


Jump-start your machine learning career

Learn top tools and techniques that FAANG recruiters are looking for.

Become a Machine Learning Engineer



Learning options: university vs. online

There are currently two main avenues for structured learning: university classes and MOOCs. There also exists a third option to simply learn from open-source documentation and online code tutorials.

This is often better suited for people who already have a background in machine learning and are more interested in learning a particular application, such as image recognition, or a specific deep learning package, such as TensorFlow, CNTK, or PyTorch.


University classes

The value of theory versus practice in university computer science classes has been hotly debated for a while. Many schools now offer “Software Engineering: Design & Implementation” classes that focus specifically on helping students build software engineering projects in a team environment.

The classes teach industry standard engineering practices during lecture and the majority of the grade is determined by the quality of the projects completed. Tests on theory are trivial or non-existent.

These types of classes are well received by students, and many signup to get experience for industry jobs or build projects to include on their resumes when recruiting.

The trend is abundantly clear: a majority of computer science students want to become engineers and work in industry, not pursue research or theoretical work in graduate school or beyond.


The theory/practice disconnect

Despite schools offering many practical software engineering, UI/UX design, and even data analytics courses, most university machine learning courses remain theoretical, especially courses concerning deep learning topics.

Students are expected to have strong math foundations and are often tested on proofs or concepts rather than their ability to code models and apply them to real world datasets.

Even coding assignments tend to reduce practical coding value by providing curated datasets, narrowing the scope of the problem to implementing certain functions, or failing to consider model tuning and performance.

Considering data preprocessing, feature engineering, and efficient model deployment make up a majority of a machine learning engineer’s time, this is a painful oversight when it comes to preparing students for industry machine learning.

Finally, the most obvious flaw to using university courses to prepare for industry machine learning is inaccessibility. University is expensive and classes take several months to complete. It is unrealistic for anyone other than an already-enrolled student to rely on university courses to arm them with the practical skills they need to land and thrive in a machine learning job.


Massive online open courses (MOOCs)

MOOCs solve the university courses’ accessibility problem by offering full classes to anyone with access to internet. They are reasonably priced or sometimes even free.

Classes consist of videos of professors giving lectures online, and downloadable assignments that can be completed locally and submitted for grading. Some even have forums and teaching assistants for real-person help.

However, at the end of the day, most deep learning MOOCs are still just university classes converted to an online delivery medium. The content remains mostly theoretical and it becomes even harder to effectively administer coding assignments that test the skills needed for industry.


Allen’s takeaways

It is undeniable that university courses and MOOCs teach significant machine learning content. The best courses provide a strong theoretical foundation for learners to conduct research and pursue graduate school.

However, there is a disconnect between teaching style and content and the skills needed to become an industry engineer, is what inspired us to create AdaptiLab.

At the heart of the problem is traditional courses give delivery through lectures (whether in person or on video). Lecture-based classes teach theory and then assign code to supplement the lecture.

AdaptiLab’s interactive courses on Educative instead frontload hands-on learning and provide immediate feedback to keep learners engaged.

The instruction style is more oriented towards building end-to-end solutions for industry applications and problems.

With Educative’s tools, you’ll have the experience you need to apply your learning on the job.


Continue reading about ML


WRITTEN BYJames Wu

Join a community of 500,000 monthly readers. A free, bi-monthly email with a roundup of Educative's top articles and coding tips.